OathDay / United States Civic Academy / Dual Citizenship After Naturalizing: What's Allowed

Citizenship · 4 min read · United States

Dual Citizenship After Naturalizing: What's Allowed

The US doesn't generally require you to give up your other citizenship when you naturalize. But the Oath of Allegiance, your home country's laws, and US tax obligations matter.

Many naturalized Americans hold dual citizenship — US plus their country of origin. The US tolerates dual citizenship in most cases, but the rules are nuanced.

What the US says.

The US neither encourages nor prohibits dual citizenship. Federal law doesn't require you to give up your other citizenship. The State Department officially recognizes that many Americans hold another nationality.

The Oath of Allegiance includes a phrase about "absolutely and entirely renounc[ing] all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty." This sounds like renunciation, but US courts have interpreted it narrowly: it's a renunciation of allegiance, not of citizenship. You don't have to give up the other passport unless your home country requires it.

What your home country says.

Each country has its own rule:

  • Allow dual citizenship: UK, Canada, Australia, Mexico, France, Italy, Ireland, Brazil, Israel, the Philippines (since 2003), Argentina, Colombia, South Africa, Dominican Republic.
  • Don't allow dual citizenship (you lose your original when you naturalize elsewhere): China, India (you can get an OCI card instead), Indonesia, Japan, the Netherlands (with exceptions), Singapore, Norway (recent changes).
  • Require you to formally renounce: Some countries require an explicit renunciation step.

If your home country forbids dual citizenship, naturalizing as a US citizen may automatically cancel your other citizenship — even though the US doesn't make you do that. Check your home country's nationality law.

Common scenarios.

Indian citizens lose their Indian citizenship when they naturalize abroad. But India offers Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) status — lifetime visa-free entry, the right to live and work in India, but not voting rights. Many Indian-Americans hold US citizenship + OCI.

Chinese citizens technically lose Chinese citizenship upon naturalizing in the US. Enforcement varies. Some travelers report being treated as Chinese nationals when entering China; others use US passports without issue.

Mexican citizens keep their Mexican citizenship. Mexico recognizes dual nationality. Many Mexican-Americans vote and own property in both countries.

UK / Canada / Australia citizens all retain their home citizenship when naturalizing in the US. Fully dual.

Tax implications.

US citizens are taxed on worldwide income regardless of where they live. Even if you live in your home country, you must file a US tax return every year if your income exceeds the threshold (~$13,000 for single filers). FBAR (Foreign Bank Account Reporting) and FATCA add reporting obligations for foreign bank accounts.

This is why some dual citizens *renounce* US citizenship after moving abroad — to escape US worldwide taxation. Renunciation requires an embassy appointment and a $2,350 fee.

Practical tips:

  • Get a US passport immediately after naturalizing. Use it to enter the US.
  • Use your home-country passport for traveling to or living in your home country (if your home country expects this).
  • Keep both passports current.
  • Be aware that some countries require their citizens to enter on their own passport — entering Mexico on a US passport may be against Mexican law for Mexican citizens.

Bottom line: the US doesn't make you choose, but your home country might. Confirm your home country's rule before naturalizing, and plan accordingly.

Related questions and lessons

  • How Long Does the N-400 Take? A Realistic Timeline
  • N-400 Document Checklist: What to Bring to Your Interview
  • What Happens at the USCIS Naturalization Interview
  • The 65/20 Rule: Citizenship Test for Older Permanent Residents