OathDay / Canada Civic Academy / Citizenship vs Permanent Residence in Canada

Citizenship · 3 min read · Canada

Citizenship vs Permanent Residence in Canada

Permanent residents enjoy most of the benefits of being in Canada. So why naturalize? Here are the differences that matter.

Many permanent residents live in Canada for decades without becoming citizens. The benefits of citizenship are real but not always essential. Here's the comparison.

Both PRs and citizens can:

  • Live and work anywhere in Canada.
  • Use Canada's universal health care.
  • Send children to public school free.
  • Open businesses, sign contracts, own property.
  • Receive most government benefits (Canada Child Benefit, GST credit).
  • Access pension plans (CPP, OAS — though OAS depends on residency years).

Only citizens can:

  1. Vote in federal, provincial, and municipal elections. PRs cannot vote.
  2. Run for office at any level.
  3. Hold a Canadian passport. PRs travel on their home-country passport, which can complicate visa-free travel.
  4. Serve on a jury.
  5. Hold certain government jobs requiring citizenship.
  6. Lose residency permanently safe. PRs can lose status if they spend too long abroad; citizens cannot.

Practical differences:

Travel: A Canadian passport gives you visa-free entry to 188+ countries (one of the strongest passports in the world). Some home countries' passports give visa-free entry to far fewer.

Sponsorship: Both PRs and citizens can sponsor spouses, partners, and dependent children. Only citizens can sponsor parents and grandparents (PRs cannot sponsor these — only citizens can).

Working abroad: As a citizen, you can spend unlimited time outside Canada without losing status. As a PR, you must spend 730 days in Canada out of every 5-year period to keep your PR card.

Education: Both PRs and citizens pay domestic tuition rates (often 50–80% lower than international student rates) at most Canadian universities.

Insurance: Some types of insurance (provincial health, EI) are available to both PRs and citizens. Some federal benefits require citizenship.

Tax obligations. Both PRs and citizens are taxed on worldwide income if they're tax residents of Canada. Citizenship does not change tax status.

Why naturalize?

  • Voting. Many newcomers find the inability to vote frustrating after years of contributing to Canadian society.
  • Travel flexibility. Canadian passport is one of the best.
  • Permanent status. No risk of losing residency through extended travel.
  • Sponsor parents. Important for many families.
  • Civic participation. Running for office, serving on juries, identifying as Canadian.

Why not naturalize?

  • Home country dual citizenship rules — some countries (India, China, Japan, etc.) cancel your original citizenship if you naturalize abroad.
  • Tax complications — particularly if you're considering moving back to your home country.
  • Time and cost — $630 fee, 12–24 months of process, study time.

Pro tip: Most permanent residents who plan to stay in Canada long-term benefit from naturalizing. The freedom to travel freely, vote, sponsor parents, and never worry about residency requirements again outweighs the costs for most people.

For the citizenship test: Know that voting is a citizenship-only right; PRs cannot vote.

Related questions and lessons

  • How Long Does Canadian Citizenship Take?
  • The Canadian Oath of Citizenship
  • Canadian Citizenship Residency Days
  • Canadian Citizenship Language Requirement (CLB 4)